Stellar Price Analysis – Bullish trend coming to an end

Stellar (XLM) is a payment protocol that aims to connect banks, payment systems, and people. The current spot price is down 92% from the all-time high of US$0.72, set in January 2018. The market cap currently stands at US$1.52 billion on a 20.74 billion XLM circulating supply, with US$66 million in exchange-traded volume over the past 24 hours. XLM is now ranked 15th on the BraveNewCoin market cap table, between Monero (XMR) and Tezos (XTZ).

Stellar and the Stellar Development Foundation (SDF) were created by Jed McCaleb and Joyce Kim in 2014. The project is analogous to Ripple (XRP) in many ways, where McCaleb previously worked. The SDF was created to promote global financial access, literacy, and inclusion by expanding worldwide access to low-cost financial services, through the development and maintenance of technology and partnerships.

Watch a summary of this analysis on YouTube

The SDF leadership includes CEO Denelle Dixon and founder Jed McCaleb. The board of directors includes Stellar’s chief scientist, David Mazières, Keith Rabois, Shivani Siroya, and Greg Brockman. The SDF was incorporated in 2014 as a [non-stock nonprofit corporation](https://www.stellar.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/FILED-STELLAR-DEVELOPMENT-FOUNDATION-00594674.pdf) in the U.S. State of Delaware but is not currently an independently operated 501(c)(3), or non-profit. The SDF last [applied](https://www.stellar.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Nonprofit-Status-Memorandum-00657787xA3536.pdf) for this distinction in 2015 but has not obtained tax-exempt status.

Source: dashboard.stellar.org

For consensus, XLM originally used Federated Byzantine Agreement (FBA), which was pioneered by XRP. In 2016, Mazières switched the network to the Stellar Consensus Protocol (SCP), after the chain was unable to maintain reliable consensus.

Neither XRP nor XLM use Proof of Work or Proof of Stake, but instead use validators to confirm transactions on the network. Validators do not receive a block reward. Anyone in the XLM network can be a validator, so the user must decide which validators to trust. Ideally, each trust group, or quorum slice, has overlapping transactions with other groups, and thus can collectively achieve consensus.

SCP quorum intersections ensure that each quorum slice is always linked by one node with consensus agreement, based on a large pool of individuals or validators. There have been 125 public nodes and 70 validators active on the network over the past two days, with most of these nodes residing in the United States and Germany.

In April 2019, a team of South Korean researchers released an analysis of the SCP consensus algorithm and nodes on the network. Their findings revealed that all of the nodes are unable to run SCP if only two nodes fail, leading to a security risk. These critical nodes are controlled by the SDF. A response from Mazières confirmed that the centralization of validators is currently a weakness in the ecosystem. “Downtime does happen, so what if a set of important nodes goes down and the network halts?,” Mazières questions.

On May 15th 2019, the network stalled for 67 minutes due to an inability to reach consensus. As opposed to most other chains, which can temporarily fork when consensus is not reached, the network halted completely. Stellar developers reported the high number of new nodes were the reason for the halt, “in retrospect, some new nodes took on too much consensus responsibility too soon.” The SDF nodes were not the reason for the network failure.

Initially, the XLM genesis block minted 100 billion tokens with a 1% per year initial supply growth rate. The coins created to satisfy this yearly inflation rate were distributed through an inflation pool, including network transaction fees. In late September 2019, the SDF released a proposal to remove inflation rewards completely. The SDF believed the inflation mechanism did not benefit projects building on the platform and eventually will lead to scalability problems in the future. This change was approved by validators and took effect in November 2019.

The SDF burned 55 billion lumens in November 2019, previously earmarked for future operations costs, partnerships, and giveaways. SDF CEO Denelle Dixon told attendees at the Stellar Meridian conference, “as much as we wanted to use the lumens that we held, it was very hard to get them into the market.” The SDF continues to hold a collective 29.26 billion XLM. Binance is the largest exchange related wallet, holding 4.45% of the XLM circulating supply.

Source: stellar.expert

In late 2018, the SDF announced an up-to-500 million XLM distribution, or airdrop, through Blockchain.com, which added wallet support for the asset. The airdrop is ongoing and is touted as encouraging first-time crypto users, and the crypto-curious. Each user can receive US$25 in XLM, after KYC verification in the form of an email address and identity documentation. As of earlier this year, the distribution wallet has fallen out of the top 100 rich list, suggesting that most of the airdrop has been sent to users.

In early 2019, IBM announced the launch of World Wire, which is a payment system built on the Stellar network. Six international banks have signed letters of intent, indicating that they will either use the XLM token or issue stable coins on IBM’s service, pending regulatory review. IBM also has several validators on the Stellar chain.

In March 2019, the SDF partnered with Coinbase to give away a further one billion tokens, through a learning exercise and referrals. In September, the Stellar SDF also announced a two billion coin airdrop to Keybase users. Since these airdrops, XLM holders have increased substantially.

Source: stellar.expert/explorer/public/asset/XLM?filter=asset-holders

The SDF also partnered with Wirex, a fiat (GBP, USD, and EUR) and crypto Visa card processor. Users can earn 0.5% back in BTC after each use of the Wirex Visa card. The partnership allows users to buy, store, exchange, and spend XLM on the Wirex platform. In November 2019, XLM was also added to the Coinbase card, a similar debit Visa card. In May 2020, the SDF announced a US$5 million investment into the crypto wallet and exchange Abra. The app is available in over 150 countries worldwide and also allows for stock and ETF trading.

The wider ecosystem includes Interstellar, which allows enterprises and institutions to use, and build on, the network. Interstellar combines the Chain and Lightyear brands. Chain’s products included Sequence and Chain Core. Sequence was a cloud-based ledger service for managing balances in financial and commerce applications like wallet apps, lending platforms, marketplaces, and exchanges. Chain Core was designed to operate and participate in permissioned blockchain networks.

Another Stellar-based startup operating in Thailand, Lightnet, raised US$31.2 million in January to develop a SWIFT-like system using smart contracts and distributed ledgers. Advisors to the project include McCaleb and Mazières with investments from United Overseas Bank, HashKey Capital, Signu Capital, and Seven Bank.

Source: lightnet.io

A quick comparison between two similar networks, Ripple and Stellar, shows Ripple dominating market cap, daily transaction volume, and total fees, while Stellar dominates daily active addresses and Github commits. Both coins have an equal amount of transactions per day.

The XLM network uses a default transaction fee of 0.00001 XLM to prevent spam or Denial of Service attacks. In USD terms, XLM average transaction fees rose substantially from February to May 2019 but have since returned to the previous range (green line, chart below). Average transaction fees on the chain are much lower than most other chains, and slightly less expensive than XRP currently (red line, chart below).

Source: CoinMetrics

The current number of transactions per day on the network (line, chart below) stands at 950,000, near all-time highs. Transactions per day had essentially ranged from 100,000 to 300,000 between April 2018 and November 2019. Overall, transactions per day have increased substantially since October 2019.

The average transaction value (fill, chart below) is currently under US$1,000. Aside from the 55 billion XLM coin transaction and burn, average transaction values have ranged around US$750 since June 2018. Nearly feeless on-chain transactions often encourage lower average transaction values due to a higher number of smaller sized transactions.

Source: CoinMetrics

The 30-day Kalichkin network value to estimated on-chain daily transactions (NVT) ratio (green line, chart below) has risen significantly since January 2020 and is currently 400. Historically, an NVT below 500 for the Stellar network has signified bull market conditions. The current all-time low in NVT may be related to the 55 billion XLM coin transaction and burn, not necessarily organic market activity.

A clear downtrend in NVT suggests a coin is undervalued based on its economic activity and utility, which should be seen as a bullish price indicator. Inflection points in NVT can also be leading indicators of a reversal in asset value.

The number of monthly active addresses (fill, chart below) increased from October 2017 to April 2019, but have continued to fall over the past few months, currently around 40,000. Active addresses had spiked once a week due to the release of inflation rewards. Active and unique addresses are important to consider when determining the fundamental value of the network based on Metcalfe’s law.

Source: CoinMetrics

Turning to developer activity, the Stellar project has 71 repos on Github. In total, over 300 developers have contributed to the project, with nearly 650 commits on the main repo in the past year (shown below) and over 2,600 commits on all repos in the past year. Stellar Core v14.1 was released this week and Stellar Horizon v1.1.0 was released earlier this year.

The Stellar Github also has a repo started in September 2019 called “Slingshot” which is a “new blockchain architecture under active development, with a strong focus on scalability, privacy and safety.” Features being developed include; cloaked assets and zero-knowledge smart contracts (ZkVM), confidential assets protocol based on the Bulletproofs zero-knowledge circuit proof system, a Rust implementation of Schnorr multi-sig, an API for issuing assets using ZkVM, and a “slidechain” demo which allows a user to peg funds from the Stellar testnet, import them to a sidechain, and later export them back to Stellar.

Most coins use the developer community of GitHub where files are saved in folders called "repositories," or "repos," and changes to these files are recorded with "commits," which save a record of what changes were made, when, and by who. Although commits represent quantity and not necessarily quality, a higher number of commits can signify higher dev activity and interest.

Source: Github – stellar/stellar-core

Grassroots interest in the XLM project includes 7,900 members in 24 Stellar groups on meetup.com. Worldwide Google Trends data for the term "Stellar" has remained low throughout most of 2018, 2019, and early 2020, with the exception of a small uptick in mid-May 2019. Any small rise was likely related to several airdrop announcements and the 55 billion XLM token burn.

A slow rise in searches for "Stellar" preceded the bull run in Q4 2017, likely signaling a large swath of new market participants at that time. A 2015 study found a strong correlation between the google trends data and BTC price whereas a 2017 study concluded that when the U.S. Google "Bitcoin" searches increased dramatically, the BTC spot price dropped.

Technical Analysis

Despite several bullish consolidation attempts since 2018, XLM has been unable to develop a continuous bullish trend. The strength of any potential bullish trend reversal can be mapped using Exponential Moving Averages, Volume Profile of the Visible Range, pivot points, Ichimoku Cloud, and chart patterns. Further background information on the technical indicators discussed below can be found here.

On the daily chart for the XLM/USD pair, the 50-day Exponential Moving Averages (EMA) and the 200-day EMA crossed bullish in mid-May after a 695 day bearish trend. However, the spot price is now below both the 50-day and the 200-day EMA, signaling a pending bearish Death Cross over the next few days. The 200-day EMA at US$0.079 should now act as resistance. The yearly pivot at US$0.083 should also now act as resistance.

Volume and yearly pivot resistance sit at US$0.125 with a future potential upside target of US$0.20-US$0.23. If the current local lows break, volume support sits around US$0.037 and US$0.017. Additionally, there are no active bullish or bearish volume or RSI divergences at this time.

Turning to the Ichimoku Cloud, there are four key metrics; the current price in relation to the Cloud, the color of the Cloud (red for bearish, green for bullish), the Tenkan (T) and Kijun (K) cross, and the Lagging Span. Trades are typically opened when most of the signals flip from bearish to bullish, or vice versa.

Cloud metrics on the two-day time frame with doubled settings (20/60/120/30), for more accurate signals, are neutral: the current spot price is inside of the Cloud, the Cloud is bullish, the TK cross is bullish, and the Lagging Span is above the Cloud and below the spot price. Kijun resistance now sits at US$0.0847. The trend will now remain neutral so long as the spot price remains inside of the Cloud.

On the weekly XLM/BTC chart, Cloud metrics are mostly bearish. However, a bullish TK cross below the Cloud signifies the end of the bearish trend. The next potential trade setup is an edge-to-edge through the Cloud with a long entry near 1,000 sats in late 2020. Otherwise, any bearish trend continuation attempts will likely find support at the previous lows at 500 sats.

Lastly, the daily chart for the XLM/BTC pair, trend metrics are strongly bearish with price far below both the 200-day EMA and daily Cloud. Mean reversion to the 200-day EMA and Kijun is now more likely than further bearish continuation based on the distance to these key averages. However, price has not formed a bullish divergence on volume or RSI to signify weakening bearish momentum at the current level. In the future, sustained prices above the 900 sat resistance zone would suggest a confirmation of bullish continuation. A high volume VPVR support sits between 300-500 sats with VPVR resistance and yearly pivot at the 1,600 sat zone.

Conclusion

Despite Blockchain.com, Coinbase, and Keybase airdrops over the past two years, active addresses have continued to decline. In a likely bid to increase the adoption of XLM as a store of value, the SDF axed 55% of the total token supply late last year, as well as successfully campaigned for the removal of inflation on the network.

Transactions per day have increased dramatically over the past three months, reaching a new all-time high, as average transaction values have held near US$1,000 – USD$2,000 in the same period. Based on the growing number of partnerships, the network aims to directly compete with XRP in the payments and remittance realm, and ETH in the ICO and STO realm.

Technicals for the XLM/USD pair reveal the end of a bullish trend with a pending bearish Death Cross. Volume support sits a US$0.037 with new yearly lows likely to bring price towards the US$0.017 zone. Based on the daily Cloud, a full bullish trend reset has now occurred with future long entries above US$0.085 and short entries below the current local low.

Technicals for the XLM/BTC pair reveal an oversold bearish trend with the spot price far below the 200-day EMA and daily Cloud. After a swift 42% decline, mean reversion to the 200-day EMA and daily Kijun is now more likely than further bearish continuation. Some support is likely at each of the previous local lows over the past year, with multi-year high volume support between 300 – 500 sats.